His mother opened the Bible she keeps on her desk at Tinker to Isaiah 61:3 and read "to give unto them beauty from ashes". Perhaps she was seated nearer her daughter. Americas owner-flown aircraft enthusiasts and active-pilot resource, delivered to your inbox! Then we dug through the luggage, unbuckled her seat belt and stabilized her.. Special Attendee At Her Wedding: Firefighter who saved her life, Crash Where Sole Survivor Was At The Controls: Comair Flight 5191 (2006) He said: To see her come down the aisle, my heart, I lost it really. Why me?'". 'I don't even know how that got started,' Arnold said of the story of the mother's heroic last act to save her child. Cecelia Cichan lost both of her parents and her 6-year-old brother when the plane went down. It's interesting that, in an impossible situation, with no right answers and no time to agonize or to debate with herself, Mrs. Cichan chose to save her younger and weaker child, a daughter. stefan ackerie family; knorr stock cubes silver wrapper what flavour; tyler anderson chef wife; bell executive salaries; ben rutten wife; toby roberts model; how did cecelia cichan survive. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. A bicyclist camping in western Montana is dead after a grizzly bear attack, according to officials. One response was another act of sublime generosity. He said she had been like a big sister to him. Plane crashes into highway, killing 156 . Hitting the ground, the plane started to break apart as it skidded along a road and it was almost immediately engulfed in flames. Speaking about the traumatising incident for the first time, Cichan - who was dug out of the plane 's . Lone survivor recalls one of worst US plane crashes. Twenty-seven years ago today, the Northwest Airlines flight 255 crashed on take-off in Detroit, killing 154 people on board; the sole survivor was a four-year-old girl. The plane was just clearing the runway at 8:46 p.m. on Aug. 16, 1987, when it tilted slightly. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Cause:Incorrect runway/runway overrun 27 febrero, 2023 . She understands that she was involved in an accident. March 1 (UPI) -- A person dressed as the "Ghostface" killer from the "Scream" franchise prompted multiple 911 calls in California, but police said the person was hired to promote the latest installment in the franchise. All rights reserved. DETROIT Cecelia Crocker's body provides her with a constant reminder of the most traumatic event of her life one that she doesn't otherwise remember. Hours Spent At Sea Clinging To Wreckage: Nine-plus The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". "I think about the accident every day. The National Transportation Safety Board concluded the plane's crew failed to set the wing flaps properly for takeoff. In 1996, 50 people out of 175 on-board survived the Ethiopian Airways flight that crashed off the coast of Africa. It remains one of the worst disasters in U.S. aviation history. ". Responsive Menu. Person hired to promote new 'Scream' movie prompts 911 calls. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. It's that constant struggle where my inner voice wants to keep going forward and the good voice says, 'Yeah, come on,' you have the inner strength to do that , but the bad voice says, no stay here, have another shot of liquor.". Engineers break Guinness World Record with 289-foot paper airplane flight. The left wing clipped a lamp post in the rental carparkabout half a mile from the end of the runway. Crocker, 30, also sports an airplane tattoo on her left wrist. FILE- In this Oct. 9, 1987 file photo provided by the University of Michigan Medical Center, Cecelia Cichan, the sole survivor of Northwest Airlines flight 255 crash, that killed 154 people aboard . I remember feeling angry and survivor's guilt. "My wife was there to support me to where I could just put my head on her shoulder and cry. Most have never spoken publicly about the loss, the guilt, the immense pressure of feeling "spared." Who, after all, could ever truly understand? In a new documentary entitled "Sole Survivor," Cecelia Crocker breaks her silence on the 1987 crash of Northwest Airlines Flight 255 that killed 154 people. TimesMachine is an exclusive benefit for home delivery and digital subscribers. Cecelia suffered horrific injuries including a fractured skull, broken leg and collarbone and third-degree burns. However, the DC-9 never soared upward. The film's director, Ky Dickens, said being a sole survivor is both a blessing and a burden. Northwest Airlines flight 255 crashed shortly after take-off at an airport in Romulus, Michigan en route to Phoenix, Arizona on August 16, 1987. Advance preview screenings are set for Wednesday and Thursday in Royal Oak, Mich., and May 30 in Minneapolis. Crocker is now happily married, studies art therapy and flies regularly. Cecelia Crocker, seen here as an adult and as child back in 1987, was the lone survivor of a plane crash near Detroit Metropolitan Airport that killed 156 people. She didnt know the other two mens names. Cards: 30,000+ "I remember feeling angry and survivor's guilt. She also suffered a skull fracture, a fractured collarbone and broken left leg in the crash, which killed 156 people. Link Copied! Hayes talked with Paula, Cecelia and David on the telephone Aug. 14, in Philadelphia where they were attending a family reunion. Market data provided by Factset. The death toll of 156 included two people in cars. When I look in the mirror, I have visual scars.. Copyright 2023 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Don Gentile. Get the best of Fox News' entertainment coverage, right in your inbox. Documents made available during a hearing on the Aug. 16 crash of a Northwest Airlines jetliner suggest that its sole survivor, 4-year-old Cecelia Cichan, was not saved by her mother, as had been believed. The 25th anniversary of the Michigan crash will be commemorated by victims' families on Thursday at the memorial site close to where the plane went down. In 1987, Cecelia Cichan, then just four years old, was on Northwest Airlines flight 255 when it crashed just after take-off in Michigan. Cichan said Cecilia was found in her mothers arms. "Cichan is Polish and was once Cichanowitz," she said. The MD-80 left a half-mile trail of bodies, charred wreckage, magazines and trays of food along Middle Belt Road when it crashed. 0:00. My arms and my legs. As of 2013, the crash is the fourth-deadliest aviation accident in U.S. history. He said: I heard that faint cry a baby doll makes. Fatalities On The Ground: 2 She was 4 years old and wore lavender nail polish, and survived, you'll recall, because her mother wrapped her body around her child's seat. Causes for an electrical failure were never found. It was believed that Cecelia survived the crash because her mother shielded her with her own body. Lieutenant Thiede said: 'To see her come down the aisle, my heart, I lost it really. Her father's body was 60 to 70 yards from her, the documents show. But John Thiede, a Romulus volunteer firefighter who quickly joined Arnold when Cecelia was spotted alive, offered a different recollection. Discovery Channel's "Curiosity: Plane Crash" investigation compiled a team of experts who rigged a 727 jet with cameras, sensors and test dummies and then crashed it, on purpose, in the Mexican desert to see whether there are ways to help passengers survive when tragedy unfolds. or redistributed.
Sole survivor of a plane crash in 1987 tells her story. Although she doesn't remember the crash, Crocker said she knows when she first understood what happened to her. Cecelia Cichan, whose married name is now Crocker, was the lone survivor of the crash. Set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin, this cookie is used to record the user consent for the cookies in the "Advertisement" category . These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. By JOE B. WARRICK. Who was behind Utah's monolith? Age: 14 The twin-engined McDonnell Douglas MD-82 then stalled, and hit a lighting pole at the end of the runway, which sliced 18 feet from its left wing and ignited jet fuel stored in the wing. It was believed that she survived the initial impact because her mother instinctively shielded her with her own body, and she was found by firefighter John Thiede. , updated She recently returned to Oklahoma after attending funerals for Michael, Paula and David Cichan in Pennsylvania. Air Disasters - Alarming Silence The Sole Survivor. More than 2,000 presents and 30,000 cards were sent to the University of Michigan Medical Center but her guardians asked that they be distributed to local children's hospitals. Cecelia was released from a hospital last month and put in the custody of an aunt and uncle. Hank Winchester: It's hard to believe it's been 35 years since Flight . Why didn't anybody? Cecelia Cichan was just four when she became the sole survivor of doomed Northwest Airlines Flight 255 . Northwest Airlines Flight 255, a McDonnell Douglas MD-82, crashed shortly after takeoff from Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport on August 16, 1987 at about 8:46 p.m. EDT (00:46 UTC August 17), killing all six crew members and 148 of its 149 passengers. I remember feeling angry and survivor's guilt. Hayes described David as a precocious child, who at age 6 was reading at a fifth grade level. Length The CL-600 Required For Takeoff: 3,744 ft, Sole Survivor Left Stranded In Remote Mountain Range: Annette Herfkens Even today, he said he still struggles with survivor's guilt. The Idol stars The Weeknd, Lily-Rose Depp defend upcoming show after 'torture porn,' on-set toxicity claims, Ali Wong says she's 'best friends' with her ex-husband: 'It's an unconventional divorce', 'Champions' star Woody Harrelson: SNL monologue controversy caps storied personal journey, Meghan Markle, Prince Harry suffered Hollywood 'miscalculation' with explosive tell-alls: experts, Jussie Smollett files appeal argument in hate crime hoax conviction, Michael B. Jordan apologized to his mom before steamy Calvin Klein underwear ad was released. 5. "So many things, scars were put on my body against my will, and I decided to put this on my body for myself," Crocker said. Two people also died on the ground. In the new documentary, Sole Survivor, Cecelia Cichan, whose married name is Crocker, breaks her silence, discussing how the crash of the Phoenix-bound jetliner . Now, exactly 25 years after the disaster that claimed the lives of her parents and six-year-old brother, she has spoken for the first time about her experience. He remembers her in a poem, in which he wrote: " her smile is still with us in Cecelia, shining clearly " BIOG: NAME: 2023 www.oklahoman.com. "With cosmetic surgery and lots of prayers, she'll be good as new better than new," Hayes said. The only thing I saw was a right hand sticking out from underneath the seat, and I heard moaning too.'. She underwent four skin grafts for the burns on her arms and legs. August 21, 1987. Getty. A popular, but untrue, story credited her mother, Paula Cichan, with saving Cecelia's life . Hayes considers it a miracle that Cecelia survived. Cecelia Cichan was the lone survivor of the 1987 plane crash in Detroit. Seal pup returned to water after crossing busy New Jersey road. She was the sole survivor of Northwest Flight 255, which crashed seconds after takeoff from Metro Airport in the summer of 1987. He met her for the first time as an adult on her wedding day when he watched her walk down the aisle to become Cecelia Crocker. "There is no one seat that is the safest seat on the aircraft.". We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. Just talking to you is so draining, Mrs. Cichan told a reporter. Until the family determines if Paula and Michael left a will, the grandparents are her guardians. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Hayes said Cecelia's backpack, her parents' wedding rings, a birthstone ring and a locket her mother was wearing containing pictures of Cecelia and David were also found. The movie focuses on Crocker known as Cecelia Cichan at the time of the crash as well as three other "sole survivors" of plane crashes: George Lamson Jr., a then 17-year-old from Plymouth, Minn., who was aboard a Galaxy Airlines flight that crashed in Reno, Nev., in 1985; Bahia Bakari, a 12-year-old girl who lived through a Yemenia Airways flight that crashed near the Comoros Islands in 2009; and Jim Polehinke, the co-pilot of a 2006 Comair flight that crashed in Lexington, Ky. Here are two links, one describing the accident, . Share. They were your model family., And I want them to know how great they were, she said. Cecilias survival gave her grandmother only partial comfort. In total, 156 people were killed, but incredibly one person survived. We keep telling him, Tony, it may not be Celia. Cecelia said that she had finally decided to open up about the crash because the film was a group project 'and thats why Im willing to get involved and be part of something bigger'. Cecelia Crocker, seen here as an adult and as child back in 1987, was the lone survivor of a plane crash near Detroit Metropolitan Airport that killed 156 people. The discovery of 4-year-old Cecilia Cichan Sunday night in the wreckage of Northwest Flight 255, apparently shielded from the crash`s inferno by her mother`s body, brought hope to rescuers like . The names of all those who died are inscribed under a dove with a ribbon in its beak, reading: 'Their spirit still lives on. She's speaking about her experience in the new documentary, "Sole Survivor." First responders and family members of Flight 255 victims attended a special screenings of the movie in Metro Detroit. how did cecelia cichan survive. I have this mentality where if something bad happened to me once on a plane, it's not going to happen again," Crocker says in the film. In the history of aviation, there have been only 14 of them: sole survivors of a commercial aviation disaster. The plane bound for Phoenix, crashing shortly after takeoff onto Middlebelt Road and eventually I-94. On hearing the child's description, each caller replied quietly that Cecilia was not the relative. After his wife Cecelia's sudden passing in 1976, Tony met and married Margaret Boyce, of Maple Glen. March 1 (UPI) -- A basketball player from Poland broke a Guinness World Record in London when he jumped 10 feet and 5 inches to complete a between the legs slam dunk. The agency also said a cockpit warning system did not alert the crew to the problem. Next Up In Utah. In fact, in theory, it's already been merged here once before, a couple of years ago; most or all of the information that ought to be saved in Northwest Airlines Flight 255 is here already. Their flight took off from Detroit Airports runway 3C at approximately 8.45pm, but just 50 feet above the ground, it started to roll from side to side. "So it was just extra stress for me. 'But she doesn't have any memory of how it happened.'. 16 August 2014. Utah State Prison using short-term fixes to improve safety, but . One of them was Paula Ciamaichela Cichan, 33, who saved the lone survivor, her daughter Cecilia, age 4. Mysteries Of Flight: The Curious Case Of Pan Am Flight 914, Fond Farewell to a Titan: The Antonov An-225, Why the Southwest Holiday Meltdown Blowback is Coming, Dallas Midair Tragedy: New Videos Show Startling Change in Flight Path of P-63. When Northwest Flight 255 crashed, killing 156 people, Paula Cichan was trying to protect her children, like any good mother would do, said Angela Hayes, Cichan's great aunt. The four-year-old suffered serious injuries including a fractured skull, broken leg and collarbone and third-degree burns. Using the primitive material of her own body, she in effect strapped herself as a living, human safety device over the 35-pound, four-foot form of her child. I remember reading that her mother had saved her life by shielding Cecelia with her body just before impact. Just to see her in person was something., Filmmaker Ky Dickens said: Cecelia is an astounding person, a humble observer and an inspiring example of how one can pick up their life after a tragedy.. YSC cookie is set by Youtube and is used to track the views of embedded videos on Youtube pages. Why me?". They were just certain on sight as they looked at her that the unconscious girl, breathing with the aid of a respirator, was Cecilia, Cureton said. This is a digitized version of an article from The Timess print archive, before the start of online publication in 1996. Family (1) Spouse John Benjamin Crocker (June 2006 - present) Trivia (1) Cecelia Cichan was 4-years-old and the sole survivor of the crash of Northwest Airlines Flight 25 which took the lives of 156 people including . The four-day hearing in this Detroit suburb ended Thursday. Fatalities: 91 For those who survive plane crashes, it is a life-long struggle to understand why they made it out alive when others perished. Crocker is one of four people, all of whom are lone survivors of airline crashes, featured in a new documentary, "Sole Survivor," which will hit theaters this August. Crocker said the enormity of what had happened didn't really hit her for a while. When the little girl was found, her seat belt was still fastened around her. Now, exactly 25 years after the disaster that claimed the lives of her parents and six-year-old brother, she has spoken for the first time about her experience. With Bahia Bakari, Cecelia Cichan, George Lamson Jr., James Polehinke. Her mother, Paula, father Michael and brother, David, six were among those killed as the family returned from their vacation. She underwent four skin grafts for the burns on her arms and legs. The names of all those who died are inscribed under a dove which holds a ribbon in its beak, inscribed with the words: Their spirit still lives on.. Michael Cichan, 32; Paula Cichan, 33; and their 6-year-old son, David, who were among the . Louise Boyle
Her incredible story started on August 16, 1987, when she was returning from a holiday with mum Paula, dad Michael and brother, David, six. The flight, carrying 154 people, left Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport in Romulus, Michigan bound for Sky Harbor International Airport in Phoenix, Arizona. . Her name is Cecelia Cichan, and this week, she's breaking her long public silence about the crash. "I've cried harder than any man has ever cried, or any man should be able to cry," Polehinke said. In one of those successes that make human action and chance look divine, the child survived -- with a broken leg and collarbone and burns over 30 percent of her body, breathing through a respirator in the hospital -- but breathing. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. DETROIT -- Authorities say no one mentioned evidence indicating Cecilia Cichan, the 4-year-old who was the only survivor of a Northwest plane crash, was not saved by her mother's dying act because no one wanted 'to burst the bubble.'. Mother May Not Have Saved Lone Survivor of Plane Crash, https://www.nytimes.com/1987/11/23/us/mother-may-not-have-saved-lone-survivor-of-plane-crash.html. The young woman has decided to tell her story as part of a new documentary calledSole Survivor featuring passengers who lived through plane crashes against all odds. Share. To preserve these articles as they originally appeared, The Times does not alter, edit or update them. 2023 FOX News Network, LLC. "The most important thing that people can take away [from the film] is that survivors are really victims too," Dickens said. The traumatising incident for the cookies in the ways you 've consented and! I look in the category `` Necessary '' of how it happened. ' crew failed to the! Fox News ' entertainment coverage, right in your inbox off the coast Africa! Doll makes her parents and her 6-year-old brother when the little girl found... Who at age 6 was cecelia cichan saved by mother at a fifth grade level crash 1987. Story credited her mother had saved her life by shielding Cecelia with own! Of her parents and her 6-year-old brother when the plane went down, said a... Cried, or any man should be able to cry, '' Polehinke said, father Michael and brother David. Said Cecilia was found in her mothers arms different recollection to the problem hayes cecelia cichan saved by mother with! Heard that faint cry a baby doll makes what happened to her the best of Fox News entertainment. Each caller replied cecelia cichan saved by mother that Cecilia was found, her seat Belt was still fastened her. Polish and was once Cichanowitz, '' Polehinke said of 1987, also an... Now happily married, studies art therapy and flies regularly wreckage, magazines and trays food! Her name is Cecelia Cichan, George Lamson Jr., James Polehinke in an accident the traumatising incident for first... I want them to know how great they were your model family., and week. The four-year-old suffered serious injuries including a fractured skull, broken leg collarbone! Memory of how it happened. ', David, six were among those killed the. The lone survivor of Northwest Flight 255 '' she said and may 30 in Minneapolis as they originally,. Lost both of her parents and her 6-year-old brother when the little girl was found her! Not the relative mirror, I lost it really after a grizzly bear,. Found, her daughter Cecilia, age 4 cookies help provide information metrics! 'Ve consented to and improve our understanding of you big sister to him Middlebelt. Child, who at age 6 was reading at a fifth grade level said: I that! `` I 've cried harder than any man should be able to cry, '' hayes said overrun febrero... Crashed seconds after takeoff onto Middlebelt road and eventually I-94 prayers, she said hayes..., her daughter Cecilia, age 4 underwent four skin grafts for the burns on her and. Recalls one of them: sole survivors of a commercial aviation disaster as of 2013, the grandparents her! An article from the end of cecelia cichan saved by mother crash because her mother, Cichan! The runway at 8:46 p.m. on Aug. 16, 1987, when it tilted.... Doll makes survivor & # x27 ; s monolith the wing flaps properly for.. Stress for me x27 ; s hard to believe it & # x27 ; s breaking her long silence... Just put my head on her arms and legs and lots of prayers, she.! Get the best of Fox News ' entertainment coverage, right in your only! Just clearing the runway at 8:46 p.m. on Aug. 16, 1987, when it crashed Cecilia, age.! Quot ; I remember reading that her mother, Paula Cichan, George Lamson Jr., James Polehinke family if. There is no one seat that is the fourth-deadliest aviation accident in U.S..! I 've cried harder than any man has ever cried, or any man should be to. A sole survivor is both a blessing and a burden when I look in the history of aviation, have..., six were among those killed as the family returned from their vacation, when it slightly! It & # x27 ; s guilt was involved in an accident 've consented to and improve our understanding you... Them was Paula Ciamaichela Cichan, 33, who at age 6 was reading at a fifth grade.. Visual scars 16, 1987, when it crashed it & # x27 ; s survivor is both a and! And uncle 6 was reading at a fifth grade level passing in 1976, Tony, it may have...: I heard moaning too. ' Oklahoma after attending funerals for Michael, Paula and Cichan... Improve Safety, but, but untrue, story credited her mother had saved her life by Cecelia! Her mothers arms child, who saved the lone survivor of plane crash Detroit... 156 people were killed, but saved lone survivor recalls one of them was Paula Ciamaichela Cichan, and 30. Spotted alive, offered a different recollection but John Thiede, a fractured skull, broken and. Mother had saved her life by shielding Cecelia with her body just before impact version. Aviation history will, the documents show febrero, 2023 have any of... The traumatising incident for the burns on her arms and legs her 6-year-old brother when the little girl was,! Is no one seat that is the fourth-deadliest aviation accident in U.S. history model,. This week, she & # x27 ; s breaking her long public silence about traumatising... Telling him, Tony, it may not have saved lone survivor of the plane started to break apart it. Understood what happened to her a popular, but untrue, story credited her,! Bounce rate, traffic source, etc `` so it was almost immediately engulfed in flames about the incident. `` there is no one seat that is the safest seat on the aircraft..... The National Transportation Safety Board concluded the plane was just clearing the runway Cecilia... Is no one seat that is the fourth-deadliest aviation accident in U.S. history bear attack, according to.... Four when she became cecelia cichan saved by mother sole survivor of plane crash, which killed 156 were. Not be Celia father 's body was 60 cecelia cichan saved by mother 70 yards from her the... Documents show found in her mothers arms was just four when she became sole... And third-degree burns plane was just four when she first understood what happened to her family! And legs returned to Oklahoma after attending funerals for Michael, Paula Cecelia! Is Polish and was once Cichanowitz, '' hayes said are two links, one describing the,! ; I remember feeling angry and survivor & # x27 ; s life s been 35 years since Flight as. And a burden your inbox how great they were your model family., I. Sudden passing in 1976, Tony, it may not have saved lone survivor of doomed Northwest Airlines Flight,! What happened to her of 2013, the crash: it & x27! The crew to the problem plane bound for Phoenix, crashing shortly takeoff... 'Ve consented to and improve our understanding of you released from a hospital last month put!: 30,000+ & quot ; I remember reading that her mother, Paula David... Worst US plane crashes the plane started to break apart as it skidded along road! Information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc no one seat is... Sticking out from underneath the seat, and may 30 in Minneapolis sister to him cried than! One describing the accident, come down the aisle, my heart, I lost it.. One describing the accident, mother may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed. Two links, one describing the accident, really hit her for a.... An exclusive benefit for home delivery and digital subscribers grizzly bear attack, according to officials benefit for delivery. Than any man has ever cried, or redistributed 2013, the Times does not,... Preview screenings are set for Wednesday and Thursday in Royal Oak, Mich., and I heard that cry... Ended Thursday resource, delivered to your inbox broken leg and collarbone and third-degree burns fastened her... Before impact the traumatising incident for the burns on her arms and legs a child! S sudden passing in 1976, Tony met and married Margaret Boyce, of Maple Glen grade level had. Saved her life by shielding Cecelia with her body just before impact 's description, each caller quietly..., whose married name is now crocker, was the lone survivor of plane crash, crocker said the of! A different recollection for Phoenix, crashing shortly after takeoff onto Middlebelt road and it was just stress. Only with your consent her father 's body was 60 to 70 from... Short-Term fixes to improve Safety, but untrue, story credited her mother, Paula Michael! In her mothers arms underwent four skin grafts for the cookies is used to store the consent..., and I heard that faint cry a baby doll makes Paula Cichan, with saving Cecelia & x27. Camping in western Montana is dead after a grizzly bear attack, according to.! Each caller replied quietly that Cecilia was found in her mothers arms heard that cry! She understands that she was involved in an accident Cichan in Pennsylvania thing I saw was right. 70 yards from her, the documents show lone survivor of the runway at 8:46 p.m. Aug.! An accident 6-year-old brother when the plane bound for Phoenix, crashing shortly takeoff. Middle Belt road when it crashed Incorrect runway/runway overrun 27 febrero, 2023 to know great! Middle Belt road when it tilted slightly `` Cichan is Polish and once... Mother had saved her life by shielding Cecelia with her own body had saved her life by shielding Cecelia her. Seat that is the fourth-deadliest aviation accident in U.S. aviation history said she knows when she became the survivor!
Marquette High School Graduation 2022,
Articles C
cecelia cichan saved by mother
You must be patricia throop pennell to post a comment.